#27 Pay Peanuts, Get Monkeys

Responsible sourcing is an increasingly important aspect of ESG.

But many companies mistakenly view this as another cost burden.

Screening suppliers for ethical and environmental standards does limit your choices.

And those suppliers will likely be charging higher prices — which is to be expected if they're running their companies to higher standards.

At first glance, this looks like a hit to margins.

But what if it’s actually a competitive advantage?

What if cutting corners on suppliers is already costing your company far more than it saves?

Because the real cost isn’t just in the price you pay — it’s in mistakes and failures, hidden risks, and lost opportunities.

And the companies that get this right are growing their bottom line at twice the speed of their peers.

2 min read

The ESG Cost Myth

B Corp certification requires it.

Investors, lenders, and customers are demanding it.

Yet responsible sourcing is still seen as a compliance tick box — when it should be treated as a source of value creation.

Why?

Because the biggest hidden costs in your supply chain come from suppliers chosen purely on price.

• Missed deadlines that disrupt operations and impact customer trust.

• Quality failures that lead to rework, waste, and higher costs.

• Reputational damage if a supplier is caught in controversy.

Each of these has a real financial impact — but is rarely accounted for in decision-making.

And then there’s the opportunity cost.

When your low-cost supplier isn’t up to the task, what is the value of the deals you can’t deliver on and the growth you miss out on?

Opportunity Costs

If you’ve ever been let down by a supplier, you’ve already felt this cost.

But how much has it really impacted your business in the last 12 months?

Here's how to quantify it:

1. Estimate the value of sales that were lost due to supplier failures in the last year.

2. What was the gross profit lost from those opportunities?

3. What were the additional costs you incurred in fixing the problems caused by supplier mistakes?

4. Combining lost gross profit with additional costs gives you the total impact on your bottom line.

5. Now multiply that by an appropriate EBITDA multiple.

That’s the full impact on your company’s valuation from choosing suppliers that cut corners.

Now let’s look at the upside that can be unlocked with a different approach.

From Compliance to Competitive Advantage

The trick is not just to find suppliers that meet your compliance requirements — but to find the ones that achieve those standards because it aligns with their purpose.

Because those suppliers will share your values.

And that is a much stronger foundation for a supplier relationship than a purely transactional one driven by cost.

Suppliers that are genuinely aligned with your values will go the extra mile to support you: to get a game-changing deal over the line, to meet a seemingly impossible client request, to navigate a crisis.

They help you innovate, unlock efficiencies, and land major opportunities.

They are partners more than suppliers, and will be the ones that push you to improve, innovate, and unlock efficiencies.

When ESG is done well, it doesn’t just reduce risk — it drives growth.

That’s why companies with deep supplier relationships grow their bottom line 2x faster than their peers.

And it’s why responsible sourcing isn’t a cost — it’s an investment.

Time to rethink your supply chain?

Want to explore how ESG can drive measurable financial results?

Get in touch and I’d be happy to discuss this with you.

The journey towards a better way of doing business

We are on the cusp of a new paradigm of responsible business, and helping impactful companies pair purpose with profit will accelerate the shift.

I believe this holds the key to solving many of our greatest challenges and inspiring positive change throughout society.

If you can think of one or two others that would find this newsletter helpful, please invite them to join at this link.

Thanks for your support.